Bernie Miklasz Show: Trade Contreras?

October 13, 2024 00:37:22
Bernie Miklasz Show: Trade Contreras?
The Bernie Miklasz Show
Bernie Miklasz Show: Trade Contreras?

Oct 13 2024 | 00:37:22

/

Show Notes

This is my second video that examines potential trade pieces the Cardinals have to offer other teams as they enter a rebuilding phase. In my first video in this series, I discussed the possibility of trading closer Ryan Helsley -- and it makes sense to do so because of the current circumstances.

Today's video: trade candidate Willson Contreras, the catcher and DH. It's a complex. Over the last two seasons Contreras has been the top-hitting catcher in the majors ... but isn't nearly as effective offensively when he's utilized at DH. Contreras has improved defensively but is still below-average (though not terribly so.) The Cardinals have a defensive catching ace in Pedro Pages and a bat-first catcher in the young Ivan Herrera.

The Cards also have multiple catching prospects -- most notably Jimmy Crooks -- on the way. The Cardinals have a surplus of catching. In that vein, it makes sense to seriously consider a Contreras trade. He has three years and $52.5 million left on his contract.

What's the market for Contreras? And how much would the Cardinals lose offensively if they move Contreras? And do we trust John Mozeliak to make a beneficial trade? That's an unsettling thought. The Cardinals should consider moving Contreras -- but only if they receive the appropriate value in return. And I don't know if this front office is capable of gauging a player's value. Perhaps Chaim Bloom can provide some guidance.

Other Episodes

Episode 2

August 08, 2024 00:13:11
Episode Cover

The Bernie Show 080724

Should the St. Louis Cardinals bring back Paul Goldschmidt in 2025?   My name is Bernie Miklasz and I have an opinion.   Let's get to...

Listen

Episode

November 07, 2024 00:34:46
Episode Cover

Bernie Show: Arenado a go-go?

Here's an update on a recent video about Cardinals third baseman Nolan Arenado, taking a look at the reasons why it makes sense for...

Listen

Episode

October 23, 2024 00:33:38
Episode Cover

Bernie Show: Can Brant Brown save Nolan Gorman?

The Cardinals hired a new hitting coach, Brant Brown, to replace Turner Ward. Can Brown improve the performance of STL's young hitters who struggle...

Listen